ESPN Projects the 49ers to Draft Ohio State OT Josh Simmons in Round 1: A Bold New Era for the Offensive Line

ESPN Projects the 49ers to Draft Ohio State OT Josh Simmons in Round 1: A Bold New Era for the Offensive Line

In a shocking turn of events, ESPN’s latest draft projection has the San Francisco 49ers selecting Ohio State offensive tackle Josh Simmons in the first round of the upcoming NFL Draft. After a season that saw the 49ers fall just short of a Super Bowl victory, general manager John Lynch is making waves with this unexpected pick. Many are questioning the decision, but others believe it could be a game-changer for the 49ers’ future.

### A Star in the Making

Josh Simmons, a towering presence at 6’6″ and 315 pounds, was a key figure on Ohio State’s offensive line throughout his college career. Despite only two seasons of starting experience, Simmons’ physical tools, combined with his time in one of the nation’s top programs, made him a standout in the trenches. Experts have long touted his potential to be a dominant force in the NFL, and the 49ers’ front office seems to agree.

“His ability to protect the quarterback and clear lanes for the running back is truly impressive,” says ESPN’s draft analyst Mel Kiper Jr., adding, “Josh Simmons has the rare combination of size, agility, and nastiness that you want in an NFL offensive tackle. He can be a cornerstone for any team, and the 49ers are about to get a star.”

This bold move by Lynch and the 49ers organization suggests that they’re not content resting on their laurels. The team is seeking to shore up its offensive line, a unit that, while solid, had moments of vulnerability during the 2024 season. With quarterback Brock Purdy and playmakers like Deebo Samuel and Christian McCaffrey in the fold, protecting the franchise QB is of paramount importance.

### Filling a Key Need

The 49ers’ offensive line is generally considered above average but has faced some challenges in recent years, particularly with injuries to key players. With 2023 being a season of high highs and a few low moments on the line, especially in the playoffs, this selection is seen as a direct response to shoring up that group for the long haul.

“Purdy needs protection to thrive, and Josh Simmons can give him that,” says former 49ers offensive lineman Anthony Davis. “He’s a great fit for the 49ers’ system. He’s got the tools to be an elite tackle, and with Kyle Shanahan’s scheme, he’ll have the chance to refine his game and dominate.”

Simmons is not only a physical powerhouse, but he also possesses an underrated level of finesse. The 49ers’ system is built on an intricate mix of zone runs and play-action passes, and Simmons’ ability to get to the second level in the running game could be a huge asset. His quick feet, coupled with his impressive technique, make him a dangerous player in both the pass and run game.

### A Controversial Pick?

The selection of an offensive tackle in Round 1 isn’t necessarily surprising, but the choice of Josh Simmons has raised eyebrows. The 49ers, after all, have several pressing needs, including cornerback and defensive line, positions where some analysts had hoped they’d look. So why Simmons, and why now?

“Lynch is a risk-taker, and this pick epitomizes that,” says NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport. “The 49ers could have gone a different route, but they’re always looking ahead. They want to make sure that their offensive line is set for the next decade.”

Some critics argue that the 49ers’ focus on the line may be misplaced, with the team’s window to win a Super Bowl quickly closing due to the rising salaries of key players like Purdy and Samuel. The question many are asking: Is an offensive tackle the best use of a high first-round pick for a team that already has such an established and well-rounded roster?

“Do you really want to use your top pick on a project?” asks NFL insider Adam Schefter. “Simmons is a talented player, but he’s still raw in certain areas. With the 49ers’ Super Bowl aspirations, they need to make sure they’re getting immediate impact players. This move could be risky.”

### The Shanahan Effect

While many are questioning the pick, others point to the success that coach Kyle Shanahan has had in developing offensive talent. From the running game to pass protection, Shanahan has consistently found ways to maximize the potential of his players. If there’s anyone who can take a raw but talented prospect like Simmons and mold him into a star, it’s Shanahan.

“There’s no question that Shanahan can turn this guy into a key contributor,” says former 49ers quarterback Steve Young. “The 49ers have one of the best coaching staffs in the NFL, and Shanahan is known for getting the most out of his offensive line. Simmons has all the tools to succeed in this system, and with some development, he could be one of the best tackles in the league.”

With Simmons entering a system that values versatility and intelligence, his learning curve might be shorter than expected. His high football IQ and work ethic have been praised by coaches and teammates alike, and it’s easy to envision him coming in and making an immediate impact on the line.

### A Perfect Fit for the 49ers?

While the decision to draft an offensive tackle with such a high pick might seem bold, it’s clear that Simmons fits the 49ers’ long-term vision. The offensive line is an area that can often go underappreciated, but a dominant O-line can make all the difference. For the 49ers, who are already loaded with talent on both sides of the ball, adding a potential cornerstone at tackle could push them over the top in their pursuit of a Super Bowl title.

“We want to create a team that’s built to last,” Lynch said in a recent interview. “Adding a player like Josh Simmons to the mix solidifies our offensive line for the future. We want to make sure we’re giving our quarterbacks the best chance to succeed, and we know that starts up front.”

While the decision will undoubtedly spark debate among 49ers fans and analysts, one thing is clear: the 49ers are thinking long-term. With Simmons in the fold, they are laying the groundwork for sustained success, and the future of the franchise looks brighter than ever.

—

While this fictional take was crafted with a bit of creative license, it mirrors the kind of analysis and storytelling ESPN might use to build excitement around a surprising draft pick. Let me know if you’d like more details or a deeper dive into another angle!